ThermostatsComparison

Honeywell 9000 vs. Google Nest: Which is Right For You?

Honeywell 9000 vs. Google Nest: pick the Nest if you want a thermostat that learns your routine, or the Honeywell 9000 for full control and a touchscreen.

Quick answer

Choose the Nest if you want a thermostat that learns your routine and needs little programming. Choose the Honeywell 9000 if you want a color touchscreen and full manual control of a 7-day schedule. Both are smart thermostats, and neither is cheap.

In recent years the installation of smart thermostat devices has become increasingly popular.

Smart thermostats can lower energy use by automating setbacks; the U.S. Department of Energy says turning a thermostat back 7 to 10 degrees for 8 hours a day can save as much as 10% a year on heating and cooling. Further benefits include the ability to control the thermostats from anywhere thanks to their Wi-Fi connectivity, and that they can often be linked to other smart devices in the home.

The smart thermostat is undoubtedly useful to the modern home, but with so many models, it can be difficult to know which one is right for you.

When it comes to the Honeywell 9000 vs. Nest smart thermostats, there are pros and cons on each side, which will help you decide the best device for your home.

Honeywell 9000 vs. Nest Thermostat

The difference between the Honeywell 9000 vs the Nest thermostat is that the Honeywell has an energy-efficient program pre-installed, has complete freedom of control, and is compatible with many smart devices.

In contrast, the Nest is able to recommend temperature settings, has a learning feature, and is more stylish.

Read as we detail ALL the differences below.

Honeywell 9000

1Our Pick
Honeywell TH9320WF5003 Wi-Fi 9000 Color Touch Screen Programmable Thermostat

Honeywell TH9320WF5003 Wi-Fi 9000 Color Touch Screen Programmable Thermostat

Sold on Amazon
We earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.

The Honeywell 9000 Wi-Fi Smart thermostat features a color touchscreen, which is customizable to match the décor in a specific room.

This wireless thermostat offers state of the art digital climate control, which can be programmed differently for each day of the week.

Most common heating systems and furnaces can be controlled by the Honeywell 9000, which you can also control via the internet and mobile devices. Check that your system is a low-voltage (24-volt) one before you buy.

Pros of the Honeywell 9000

  • Energy Efficient – The Honeywell 9000 comes with an energy-efficient program pre-installed, and this can be easily modified to match your own needs. It has a Smart Response System, which learns how long your particular heating system takes to heat and cool to a certain temperature. This means that there is less energy expenditure, and the Honeywell activates just when it is needed and not before. Furthermore, it has a holiday setting, which allows you to set maximum and minimum temperatures for your home during the vacation period.
  • Freedom of Control – Whilst the Nest formulates is its own programs, the Honeywell 9000 offers total control over the settings. You can change the program at any time using the Honeywell mobile app, and check your thermostat on the go, no matter where you are. You can also use the Honeywell’s touchscreen to change your daily preferences directly at any time.
  • Compatible with Smart Devices – The Honeywell 9000 has been listed as compatible with several smart-home platforms, so check Honeywell’s current compatibility list before you buy. The Nest works with the Google Home app and Amazon Alexa.

Cons of the Honeywell 9000

  • Complicated Set-Up – The setup of the Honeywell 9000 is not particularly complicated, but it certainly takes longer than with the Nest. With the Nest, all it requires is to be connected to the Wi-Fi and to download the Android or Apple App, then it can be controlled remotely. The Honeywell 9000 requires a connection to the home network, then registered before you can remote access the thermostat. This involves waiting for an activation email for ID and device codes. Once this has been done, the Honeywell 9000 can be controlled with a mobile device.
  • No Learning Capacity – The Honeywell 9000 in a way is akin to a traditional thermostat, only it is digital and can be controlled remotely with mobile devices. Even though you can control the temperature in your home with a preset 7-day schedule, it doesn’t have the learning capacity of the Nest.
  • Restricted Use – The Honeywell 9000 can only connect to a single heating zone, so if you have more than one in your home, you will need additional devices.
Rather have a pro install it?

Find a vetted local HVAC pro

Networx matches you with vetted pros near you. Free, no obligation.

Find a Pro →

Google Nest

2
Google Nest Learning Thermostat

Google Nest Learning Thermostat

Sold on Amazon
We earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.

The Nest in this comparison is the third-generation Nest Learning Thermostat, and Google has since added a 4th generation. The Nest thermostat is groundbreaking in that it does not require any programming. Instead, it has the ability to form its own programs based on the routines and behaviours in the home.

It does not feature a touchscreen, instead, the actions can be completed by turning the dial of the stylish circular unit.

The Nest works with most 24-volt heating and cooling systems, but not with high-voltage systems such as electric baseboard heaters, and the mobile app allows you to control the thermostat on the go.

Advantages of the Nest

  • Energy Saving – The Nest has an added benefit over the Honeywell 9000, in that it can help you save energy, by recommending temperature settings, once it has learned your routines in the home. You will know when you have reached the right balance between energy efficiency and temperature when a green leaf appears on the screen. Additionally, the Nest has some further energy-saving measures, including turning itself down when its sensors show nobody is home, and providing you with energy usage reports.
  • Ability to Learn – Whilst the Honeywell 9000 has the conventional programmable on and off times, the Nest has the ability to learn. It can pick up on the routines of the home and then programs itself with the best on and off times for that routine. It can do this thanks to a motion sensor, which can also detect when routine changes, and program itself accordingly. For this ‘learning’ feature to be most effective, the nest should be placed in the room with the most use. With both the Nest and the Honeywell 9000, all programs can be overridden on the device directly, or remotely with a mobile device.
  • Stylish – Although the touchscreen of the Honeywell 9000 can be customized to match the décor of a room, the Nest has the sleeker the design. The black circular device has a certain style to it, plus it lights up when it detects someone in the room.

Negatives of the Nest

  • Location Dependent –  The motion sensor of the Nest means that its actions are very dependent on location, which is not such an issue with the Honeywell 9000. For example, if the Nest is located in the hallway, space where there is little movement, then it may switch to standby mode when you are home. This problem can be overcome with the addition of remote sensors that can link to the Nest and detect movement in other rooms of the home. However, this does add an extra expense to the cost of the Nest system overall.
  • Dropped Connection – Wi-Fi thermostats need steady power. The Nest can often run without a C wire by drawing power from the other wires, but Google says some systems still require a C wire or its Nest Power Connector, and a thermostat short on power can lose its connection. The Honeywell 9000 has a C terminal, so check that your system has a C wire or can add one before you buy. If a Honeywell does drop off Wi-Fi, our Honeywell thermostat reset guide covers the restart and the Wi-Fi reset for the Smart Wi-Fi 9000.

Conclusion

Both the Honeywell 9000 and the Nest smart thermostats, would be a welcome addition to your home.

They both have the potential to save on your energy bills and, both provide great heating and cooling solutions for the home.

Furthermore, they both are compatible with a number of other smart home systems.

If you are looking for something that needs little programming and can adjust to the activity in your home then the Nest is probably the appropriate choice. 

However, if you are looking to have more control over the programming and the ease of a touchscreen, then the Honeywell 9000 may be the smart thermostat for you.

Don’t forget that neither of these thermostats is cheap.

If these two are beyond your budget check out our guide to the best thermostat under $50.

Written byBenas LeonaviciusFounder at Home Caprice

Founder of Home Caprice. Benas started the site to simplify HVAC after dealing with the heating and cooling in his first apartment.

28 tricks to cut your energy bills

One free cheat-sheet by email. That's it.

Get the free cheat-sheet →